Denim-wrapped Nightmares, a Supernatural podcast

Do you like Supernatural Then and Now? Well, one of our guests called Denim-wrapped Nightmares their "bratty, little sister." And you know what? Accurate! 🥂

Join SPN family newcomers, Berly and LA, as they recap the Warner Bros. CW TV series, Supernatural, episode by episode. Over drinks, they'll discuss lore, gore, and what they adore about the Winchesters and their adventures.

As a way to keep in touch during the 2020 pandemic, Berly and LA started podcasting with their debut, anything-goes talk show, The Tipsy Exchange. During those discussions, Berly and LA realized that they most enjoy talking humorously about TV/Film, mythology, suspense, and hot guys.

A Supernatural podcast seemed a natural fit. It's a match made in heaven... or hell... you decide!

Now, let's get tipsy! CW/TW for violent and lewd commentary; listeners beware! 🔞

Podcasting since 2022 • 208 episodes

Denim-wrapped Nightmares, a Supernatural podcast

Latest Episodes

Supernatural Music Extravaganza: Series Finale - Carry On My Wayward Song (Rights)

Welcome to the series finale of Supernatural Music Extravaganza! In this episode, the Denim Wrapped Nightmares and In Defense of Fandom crews tackle the eternal question: "Why does my Supernatural sound different on {insert name of str...

January 06, 2026 • Season 2025 • Episode 10 • 34:41

Supernatural Music Extravaganza: Volunteering for Mayhem - Mark Sheppard & Richard Speight, Jr.

We're nearing the end of this special collaboration between Denim-wrapped Nightmares and In Defense of Fandom. Devastating, we know, but we're going out with a bang 🥁The final Supernatural Music Extravaganza Artist-on-Artist episode feat...

December 30, 2025 • Season 2025 • Episode 9 • 1:03:36

Supernatural Music Extravaganza: Convention Carolers - Rob Benedict & Jason Manns Unwrapped

Have a Holly Jolly Christmas... with Denim-wrapped Nightmares, In Defense of Fandom, and two guys talking about their musical journey!In this first installment of the Supernatural Music Extravaganza's Artist on Artist series (aka ...

December 23, 2025 • Season 2025 • Episode 7 • 47:01

Supernatural Music Extravaganza: Driver Picks the Music - Fan Artists Take Center Stage

In this special collaboration episode between Denim-wrapped Nightmares and In Defense of Fandom, hosts LA, Berly, and Sadie dive deep into the world of Supernatural-inspired music—because apparently, watching two gorgeous brothers hunt monsters...

December 09, 2025 • Season 2025 • Episode 5 • 1:14:53

Supernatural Music Extravaganza: Splitting the Score - Two Composers, One Iconic Soundtrack

Welcome to the ultimate SPN music nerd-out! This Denim-wrapped Nightmares and In Defense of Fandom crossover dives deep into the sonic world of Supernatural with the dynamic duo behind the show's iconic score: composers Christopher Len...

November 25, 2025 • Season 2025 • Episode 3 • 1:34:28

See All Episodes

Fan Mail

I work alone as a manager at a dog grooming salon. Very rarely do i have a coworker with me. Sometimes I get these spurts of anxiety and quite literally panic that I'm alone with no support or help. Let me just say this podcast absolutely helps with that. Listening to you both talk and cut thirsty jokes about my favorite series has been an absolute joy. I love how freely you speak and your acknowledgement of the fans . I feel like im part of the gossip and judgements. You leave me conversing with you both through the screen, making corrections. Answering questions, mimicking quotes. Your podcast helps me feel less alone through my shift and I will always recommend it. Thank you so much for being a friend and entertainment.

Buffalo, New York